Taste Test is a card game designed to help founder-led CPG brands improve their creative direction
Brands Worth Buying home

Taste Test: The Calibration Deck

Make Your Standards Easier To Meet

BWB-04-TASTE

Creative judgment you can explain and share, rather than a standard the team must guess or borrow from the most senior person.

Build Judgment Beyond The Loudest Opinion

A creative-calibration game for turning personal preferences into reasoned judgments and reusable criteria grounded in evidence and brand context.

What Taste Test: The Calibration Deck helps you to do

You may know that a piece of work feels wrong without having the words to explain why. The deck gives you practice noticing the difference and stating a useful reason. Your team learns to compare choices without relying only on the most senior person’s reaction. The brand builds a shared set of creative standards that can be applied, challenged and improved as new work and evidence arrive.

Who it is for

Brand and creative teams making quality judgments

Helps you address

  • You and your team use words like premium, bold or on-brand to mean different things

  • Creative reviews become a comparison of personal favourites

  • Your team says it is hard to predict which option will be approved

  • The same references keep returning, but nobody has written down what makes them useful

Format

Print-and-cut calibration deck PDFs in single- and double-sided layouts; game guide and session record sheets as printable PDFs, with single- and double-sided options.

Minimum Requirements

Internet access; PDF viewer.

Included in

Brief To Shelf

Goal

Better Creative

Problems with a download?

Files open on desktop and mobile. If something looks broken, get in touch and we’ll sort it out.

Taste Test cover shown on a tablet
Taste Test cover shown on a tablet

Stop saying 'I just don't like it.' Show what makes the work right.

What Taste Test: The Calibration Deck helps you achieve

Help your team make creative judgements without waiting for your reaction to every option.

Build shared criteria that make creative reviews more consistent without making the work look identical.

Put different interpretations into words and leave the discussion knowing what to look for next time.

Minimum Requirements:Internet access; PDF viewer.

  • Better Output < More Output

  • Free Up Your Time

(03)

( What Can Change )

Put your creative judgment into words

You can explain what you notice and why it matters instead of asking others to trust an unexplained reaction.

Give senior opinion a fair challenge

Independent responses give the team something to compare before authority or confidence becomes the default answer.

Build standards the team can share

Useful reasons become explicit criteria that makers and approvers can apply to the next piece of work.

Build credibility through visible decision making

Participants can locate the difference in what they saw or valued, rather than treating disagreement as a personal problem.

Give weaker options a clearer direction

The team can describe what needs developing instead of stopping at a vote for the preferred version.

Keep creative standards open to learning

Recorded judgments can be revisited against later work and evidence rather than becoming permanent rules based on one session.

How Taste Test: The Calibration Deck Works

Turn personal taste into useful judgment

Build a shared way to notice, explain and discuss creative choices without letting seniority decide every answer.

01
Choose work worth comparing
Opinions need context; bring a pair of examples and a clear job to judge them against.
02
Notice before judging
Quick preferences can skip the details; write down what you see before deciding which option is stronger.
03
Explain your reasons
“I like it” gives others little to use; name the device, choice or brand requirement behind your view.
04
Make disagreement useful
Different judgments can reveal missing standards; discuss where the readings split and what would improve the work.
05
Carry the standard forward
A strong conversation is easy to forget; record useful criteria and revisit them against later work and evidence.
01
Choose work worth comparing
Opinions need context; bring a pair of examples and a clear job to judge them against.
02
Notice before judging
Quick preferences can skip the details; write down what you see before deciding which option is stronger.
03
Explain your reasons
“I like it” gives others little to use; name the device, choice or brand requirement behind your view.
04
Make disagreement useful
Different judgments can reveal missing standards; discuss where the readings split and what would improve the work.
05
Carry the standard forward
A strong conversation is easy to forget; record useful criteria and revisit them against later work and evidence.

About the creator

With over 25+ years of progressive marketing, design and ecommerce experience, Briannah has lead high-performing marketing teams in retail, government, education, creative industries, and technology in B2B, DTC and B2C.


She is passionate about helping the little guy win. So she created the BEACON framework and digital tools to help CPG Founders & Marketing leaders beat a system stacked against them, nurture their teams to tactically use AI to improve business outcomes, and create sustainable and robust growth for their brand and business.

Frequently Asked Questions about Taste Test: The Calibration Deck

Frequently Asked Questions about Taste Test: The Calibration Deck

Do we need to bring our own creative examples?


Is there a winning answer or taste score?


Can people without a creative job title take part?


What is the included guide for?


What does Taste Test not do, and when should I seek an outside review?


Join the waitlist for Taste Test: The Calibration Deck

Taste Test is a card game designed to help founder-led CPG brands improve their creative direction

Prefer to talk? My door's open.

If something here resonates and you'd like to think it through together, you're welcome to write.

No pitch waiting on the other side.

Brands Worth Buying home

YVR

49'

BEACON™ is a trademark of Super Mega Brand Ventures Inc and used under license.

Prefer to talk? My door's open.

If something here resonates and you'd like to think it through together, you're welcome to write.

No pitch waiting on the other side.

Brands Worth Buying home

YVR

49'

BEACON™ is a trademark of Super Mega Brand Ventures Inc and used under license.

Prefer to talk? My door's open.

If something here resonates and you'd like to think it through together, you're welcome to write.

No pitch waiting on the other side.

Brands Worth Buying home

YVR

49'

BEACON™ is a trademark of Super Mega Brand Ventures Inc and used under license.